Well, luckily I only have two faithful followers, one of whom was nice enough to try to grab my button. Alas, it did not work! Of course I couldn't just leave it until morning. Nope... had to fix it tonight! Went back to the drawing board because I guess it was easier to have a square design (and I was willing to try anything to make it easier), signed up for Photobucket, and started coding. Wow. This website stuff is hard! I found a great website with a tutorial that helped a newbie like me. Thought I'd share!
http://snapcreativity.com/how-to-make-a-blog-button-with-grab-box/
Kendra at Key Lime Digital Designs is a genius! Go visit her site if you want to make a button!
The one thing I kept doing wrong on Photobucket was copying the link instead of the html code for my picture. Once I figured that out (only took me an additional hour and wanting to throw my computer out the window), I was golden!
Anyway, I hope that this helps someone else. Hours of my life that I can't get back... haha. The satisfaction of knowing I learned something new makes it (almost) worth it.
So I said luckily I only have 2 followers because hopefully only Jill tried to capture my old broken button. Someone please reward my hard work and capture away... did I say please? Did I mention how hard I worked? :) Ok, off to bed!